The Daily Telegraph, 24 April 2004
By Ambrose Evans-Pritchard in Brussels
Maybe it is a Tower of Babel, but at least they will be able to understand the word "no".
The entry of 10 countries into the European Union next week marks the ascendancy of English as the undisputed common language of the Brussels institutions, relegating French to an also-ran. When the incoming commissioners gather on the 12th floor of the Breydel Building in early May, some may mutter a few words in German or French out of politeness, but almost all will flip spontaneously into English once real business begins.
Poland's Danuta Hubner was educated at Sussex University and Berkeley; Latvia's Sandra Kalniete went to a Foreign Office boot camp in Leeds; Slovakia's Jan Figel and Lithuania's Dalia Grybauskaite went to Georgetown in Washington. The Cypriot and Maltese duo speak English almost as a mother tongue.
A French offer of free language teaching and gourmet cuisine at the Chateau de Correnson near Avignon does not seem likely to change the habits of a lifetime. More than 57 per cent of all European Commission documents are already drafted in English compared to 29 per cent in French and five per cent in German - the three core languages. English is automatically chosen for economic and financial reports.
Only a decade ago English was still banned in the press room, while Brussels sometimes seemed little more than an extension of the French civil service. Now the switch seems irreversible. Only 14 per cent of the candidates for EU jobs from the East European states have so far chosen French as their working language, while 69 per cent opted for English.
Jonathan Faull, the director-general of justice and home affairs, who is bilingual, said a revolution had taken place since he arrived in 1978. "It's changed enormously. Then everything was in French and it was very rare to see an internal memo in English."
With the switch in language comes conceptual advantage, subtly feeding the "Anglo-Saxon" way of thinking into the EU system. "Some of my French colleagues complain that we have not only brought Shakespeare but also Milton Friedman and Margaret Thatcher, and they may have a point," said one British official.
France's EU ambassador, Pierre Sellal, has been fighting a rearguard campaign to save French in Brussels, saying language is crucial to "the modes of perception that shape the European system". But if day-to-day business changes to English, or rather "Le Bad English" as the mash of mangled syntax and bureaucratic jargon has come to be known, all new rules and directives will still have to be translated into a tongue that can be read by all 450 million citizens of the enlarged EU.
Never easy - "copyright" was once translated as "a right to copy" in the French text - the turnout will soar from 1.4 million to 2.4 million pages a year as the newcomers raise the number of official languages from 11 to 20. A growing army of 1,200 translators and 700 interpreters will be on call at a cost of £700 million a year. They can earn up to £80,000 a year, plus perks and allowances. The ultimate target: 80 interpreters per language per day for 11,000 meetings each a year, even if most end up speaking with nobody listening.
The scale of the challenge was all too visible when Sandra Kalniete tried to conduct her ratification hearing by MEPs in Latvian. By the time questions on farming had been relayed from Greek and Italian through the "pivot" language of English into Latvian they had become so garbled that she ripped of her earphones and switched to English.
- ► 2011 (1596)
- ► 2010 (1372)
- ► 2009 (1557)
- ► 2008 (1456)
- ► 2007 (1691)
- ► 2006 (1471)
- ► 2005 (1784)
- Wrong England?
- EU fisheries control agency
- UKIP to spend £2 million
- For Europe’s sake…
- And whose fault is that?
- Well, thank goodness for that …
- The marching morons
- The navel of Europe
- All in a spin
- Number of EU Regulations
- Chirac refuses to commit on referendum
- UK “can vote no and stay in EU”
- The Party’s over – before it’s begun
- The Great Debate?
- Prodi worried – Chirac pressured
- The view from Ireland
- An epidemic of rhetoric
- Daniel Hannan's Euro-briefing
- Stitch-up in progress?
- Commission intervenes on Italy’s deficit
- Parliamentary accountability – EU style
- More Bananas
- Mr Blair goes to Europe
- Survey confirms trend
- He is “our” terror master now
- We have a deal – for the moment
- Who are we?
- Poland to join the referendum gang
- German journalist’s office is raided by Belgian po...
- Voting ‘yes’ is rewarded after a fashion
- French want a referendum
- EU is 'chaotic and leaderless'
- Treaty to test the strongest constitution
- Update on EU Constitution negotiations
- Czech president says EU stifling freedom
- Of mushroom and crises
- Wrong enemy?
- More on the ratification question
- Woolly thinking from UKIP
- Accountability? Whose accountability?
- The EU’s ‘ethical’ foreign policy
- Compare and Contrast
- Welcome to Our Prison House of Nations
- British Ministers on the Defensive
- Here we go again
- Euro MP silent
- Insight into that constitution
- Pull out of Europe, said Mr Blair
- Owen Paterson MP Slams EU Constitution in Principl...
- Mr Eurofighter
- How Americans see it
- The voice of the enemy
- As the old boxing cry had it: “We Wuz Robbed!”
- Myth of the Week
- Dealing with Fraud – the European Way
- Patten intervenes
- More on those polls
- Booker Notebook
- Workers of the World Unite - but not in Europe
- A very dangerous precedent
- It's the fishing industry stupid!
- New fishing commissioner a Latvian diplomat
- How they see it in Washington
- BNP - straws in the wind?
- Two thirds want to stay in EU
- E-day puts EU flags in short supply
- Comment by Peter Troy
- Blair told ballot was risky
- French an also-ran as English tops the EU
- No "plan B" for the constitution
- Do we really want to be part of this?
- Walking the walk
- Germans favour EU referendum
- Stakeholders and chips
- FSB - on the sidelines?
- 'No' campaigners desperate to sideline hardline Eu...
- Has Blair run out of choices?
- The EU Constitution: Threat or Opportunity?
- A letter to Michael Howard
- Danger, democrats at work
- Firms say no to EU sign-up
- This is what we are voting for
- Czech president slams European Union
- The European Council
- A new blog on the street
- ▼ April (88)
The Daily Telegraph, 24 April 2004